Disclosure: Some products in this post were sent by Zoya for review.
So glad that many of you found my comparisons yesterday helpful! More today. LOTS more.
First of all, here are three polishes that I’ve swatched in the past but will not be comparison swatching today because they aren’t even remotely similar like I thought at first:

(l to r) Solange, Ziv, and Piaf, all from Zoya. Solange is a yellow-gold matte textured PixieDust, Ziv is a metallic true gold foil, and Piaf is a very light yellow shimmer.
Let’s look at dark oranges:

(l to r) Zoya Milla, Zoya Myrta, JulieG/Jesse’s Girl Sugar Rush, and Zoya Destiny.
Milla is a coral-pink-orange jelly with some gold flakes, Myrta is a medium-dark orange foil from last year’s fabulous Surf Collection, and Sugar Rush and Destiny are matte textured polishes.
All photos are under indirect outdoor light, and again, I’m holding a bottle of Zoya’s Raven for contrast.

I’d consider Sugar Rush and Destiny duplicates. Their formula (excellent), color, and finish are all so close I don’t think I could tell them apart. Myrta is a great foil and Milla is a pretty polish that doesn’t get near the love I think it deserves. You could do a jelly sandwich manicure with it.
Now, silvery lavenders:

(l to r) Zoya Julie, Milani Hi-Res, JulieG Crushed Candy, and Zoya Stevie. OPI Can’t Let Go is hovering in the upper right corner only because it’s another purple matte textured polish, but as you can see, it’s much darker and more blue-toned than the others and I won’t be swatching it today. You can see my swatches of it here, and I like it a lot, but it is quite dark.
Julie is a light shimmer, Hi-Res is a very glossy holographic glitter (unfortunately discontinued but I see it for sale online occasionally), and Crushed Candy and Stevie are matte textures.

No dupes. Crushed Candy is more pink and has larger glitter than Stevie. Julie and Hi-Res have completely different finishes.
Since we’re looking at these, let’s bring back Miranda from yesterday. I turned these bottles — Miranda, Crushed Candy, and Stevie — sideways so you could see more of the polish.

Crushed Candy seems to be a color in between the pink of Miranda and the lavender of Stevie. I LOVE all three.

Let’s move from pink to red:

(l to r) Zoya Miranda, JulieG Hot Cinnamon, and Zoya Chyna.

No duplicates. All are pretty; Chyna has more of a ruby tone.
Even though I showed blue ones yesterday, I want to revisit Zoya Liberty and compare it to JulieG Blueberry Fizz and Zoya Nyx:


Gee, why did I even show Liberty again? Not even close. Blueberry Fizz and Nyx are similar but not dupes — Blueberry Fizz is more of a sky blue and has larger silver glitter, and Nyx is thinner and more steel blue.
Finally, just because I can, here are JulieG Rock Candy and Zoya Vespa compared to each other:


Not close. Rock Candy is thicker, more of a teal green, and has larger silver glitter, while Vespa is thinner and a light gray-green.
Whew! Hope I haven’t overwhelmed you with samples and comparisons. Of all the polishes today the only true duplicates in my opinion are JulieG’s Sugar Rush and Zoya’s Destiny. Both are excellent polishes from great companies. The JulieG polish is less expensive but the bottles are smaller as well.
Disclosure: Some products in this post were sent by Zoya for review.
Like this:
Like Loading...